West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt and four others have been indicted by a federal grand jury in two alleged schemes involving the theft of tax-delinquent properties and fraudulent payments of state wages, federal prosecutors announced Monday.
Hunt, 66, of Charleston, is accused of using his position to improperly transfer nine properties in Kanawha and Boone counties to benefit a longtime friend and business associate, according to indictments announced Monday by U.S. Attorney Moore Capito.
Three other men were indicted in the alleged property scheme. They include David Keith Cole, 57, deputy chief of staff for the auditor’s office and office manager of Hunt’s private law firm; Frederic Scott Caudill, 59, general counsel for the auditor’s office; and Robert Lisle Johns, 66, a longtime friend and business associate of Hunt who serves as special counsel in the auditor’s office. All three are from Charleston.
Each of the four faces nine counts of theft of property. Cole and Caudill also face one count each of making false statements to federal investigators.
“Public officials are entrusted to serve the people, not use their offices for personal benefit,” Capito said in a statement. “When there is evidence that trust has been violated, our office will follow the facts and enforce the law, regardless of title or position.”
Alleged property scheme
According to prosecutors, Johns was associated with a business entity seeking to purchase nine tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties.
Career employees in the auditor’s office determined that the properties were legally ineligible for deed issuance because the purchaser had missed required payment and paperwork deadlines.
Despite their objections, Hunt allegedly signed and issued deeds for eight properties on March 28, 2025, and the ninth on June 6, 2025. Prosecutors allege Cole and Caudill helped create and issue the deeds, effectively stealing the properties from their lawful owners.
Johns was hired as full-time special counsel for the auditor’s office in June 2025.
Caudill and Cole are also accused of lying to FBI agents during separate interviews in October 2026 about the disputed deeds. Cole allegedly made false statements about approving falsified government timecards, while Caudill allegedly lied about whether he had asked employees “who will be the whistleblower” concerning the deeds.
Alleged bank fraud scheme
A separate indictment charges Hunt, Cole and Marie Ann Hoffmann, 66, of Hurricane, in an alleged scheme to pay Hoffmann state wages for work performed at Hunt’s private law firm, Mark A. Hunt & Associates.
Between May 2025 and at least September 2026, Hoffmann, a full-time auditor’s office employee, allegedly left her government workplace on Friday afternoons to perform paralegal and administrative work at the firm.
Prosecutors allege Hunt and Cole frequently worked alongside her during state business hours. Cole allegedly approved Hoffmann’s falsified government timecards with Hunt’s knowledge, allowing her to collect state wages for work she did not perform for the auditor’s office.
Hoffmann faces a bank fraud charge, with Hunt and Cole accused of aiding and abetting the offense. Prosecutors allege the payments were processed through the bank serving as the West Virginia Treasury’s primary state depository.
The FBI and West Virginia Commission on Special Investigations investigated the cases. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Jonathan T. Storage and Joshua Hanks are prosecuting.
All five defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.




